How to read the evidence
The Ascent
Every cure that ever reached a human hand climbed the same mountain. Most fall on the way. We tell you where on the mountain each one stands.
- Lab & animalFirst lightCells or animals only. Most never reach people.
- Phase 1First stepsFirst in humans. Small, mainly safety and dose.
- Phase 2Early signalDoes it work? Hundreds of people, early efficacy.
- Phase 3Weight of manyTested at scale, usually randomized against standard care.
- ApprovedIn the worldA regulator (FDA, EMA, Health Canada) has authorized it.
The five steps
Lab & animal
Cells or animals only. Most never reach people.
Phase 1
First in humans. Small, mainly safety and dose.
Phase 2
Does it work? Hundreds of people, early efficacy.
Phase 3
Tested at scale, usually randomized against standard care.
Approved
A regulator (FDA, EMA, Health Canada) has authorized it.
The source labels
Peer-reviewed journal: independent experts reviewed the paper before publication. Strong, not infallible.
Regulator decision: the FDA, EMA, Health Canada or another agency acted. We link the agency's own page.
Company-reported · not peer reviewed: numbers from a press release or investor call. Often early, always optimistic by design. We say so on every such entry.
Preprint · not peer reviewed: a paper posted before review, for example on medRxiv.
Trial registry: the public record of a study's design, on ClinicalTrials.gov or a WHO-linked registry. Registration is not a result.
News report: a journalist's account. We use it only alongside a primary source, or say clearly that the primary source could not be opened.
Words we use carefully
We avoid "cure", "miracle" and "breakthrough" as our own claims. When an expert calls something a breakthrough, we quote them by name and show the stage next to it. "Tumour shrinkage" is not "living longer", and we say which one a trial measured.